Ben Ames | published Oct, 1926

added Jun 5, 2024
cover Image
First Date of Publication
Oct, 1926
Original Source
Saturday Evening Post
Additional Publication Information
Published on Oct 9, 1926 in Volume 199, Issue 15
Original Source Type
Short Story
Original Language
Kasman Review
Other Links
Summary: A classic puzzle about “negative coconuts”… woven into a puzzle tale…

Story Tag Line: …in the morning they divided what coconuts were left, and they came out in five equal shares.”
He added morosely, “Of course each one must have known there were coconuts missing; but each one was guilty as the others, so they didn’t say anything.” Marr asked sharply, “But what’s the question?“.
“How many coconuts were there in the beginning?” Wadlin meekly explained…

Back Images:
Back Image
Back Image


  • Vijay Fafat
    Published on

    The story is a very nicely written tale of one man, Wadlin, whose only passion in life is mathematics - numbers, puzzles, Diophantine equations (“indeterminates”), statistics. As the author describes it in snippets:

    “The multiplication table to him was sweeter than the Song of Songs […] To divide a number into its factors delighted him [..] An incorrect equation was to his eyes the ugliest thing in nature. […] To his eyes, 2-4-6-8-10 was a thing of beauty; 3-6-9 had an exotic charm”.

    Wadlin works for a construction company owned by an honest proprietor, Dean Story. Story’s rival, Marr, has a much larger company in the same field and he’s unscrupulous, to boot. Marr’s one weakness is a passion for numbers and a belief in his own mathematical abilities far larger than his actual capability in the field.

    The two companies end up as bidders for a hospital project and Wadlin comes to understand that Marr might use under-handed tactics to outbid Story. He arranges matters so that the night before the bidding, Marr gets tangled up in a Diophantine puzzle which he’s unable to solve. As he loses himself in the intricacies of the puzzle, staying up all night, he ends up missing the auction. Honesty and Math win, hurray! This has shades of Nelson Bond’s “The Geometrics of Johnny Day” (published much later), which also has a math problem flummoxing dishonest competition.

    The puzzle itself is the famous “Monkey and the Coconuts” puzzle, which has been analyzed in detail in Martin Gardner’s “The Colossal Book of Puzzles”, as also on Wikipedia.