The Pikestaffe Case

Algernon Blackwood | published 1924

added May 31, 2024
cover Image
First Date of Publication
1924
Original Source
Tongues of Fire and Other Sketches
Additional Publication Information
The story was also made into a 1962 TV episode of "Tales of Mystery".
Original Source Type
Anthology
Medium
Novella
Original Language
English
Kasman Review
ISFDB
Tags
Summary: A strange tale of a professor of mathematics finding a way into another dimension through an antique mirror…

Story Tag Line: “Beyond, behind, stretching in all directions, she affirms, was empty space that produced upon her the effect of the infinite heavens as seen in a clear night sky. This space was prodigious, yet in some way not alarming. It did not terrify; rather it comforted, and, in a sense, uplifted. A diffused soft light pervaded the huge panorama. There were no shadows, there were no high lights.”


Reviews

  • Vijay Fafat
    Published on

    This quite unsatisfying yarn hangs its hat on the old idea of finding a way into a mirror to discover a new reality. The author waves his hands quite a bit to build an aura of mystery (by appealing to silky cobwebs, creaky house, age-old mirror) and plausibility (throwing buzzwords about mathematics which don’t lead anywhere - except inside the mirror, apparently) but does not appear to know how to end it, leading to a very flat story (only slightly better than a couple of his other efforts listed on the site).

    So this mathematics professor (“Mr. Thorley is a high mathematician. He makes measurements and calculations”) who reads “Gauss! Minkowski! Lobatchewski! Einstein!” takes up lodging at an old woman’s guest-house and starts performing some experiments with an antique mirror in the house (going so far as to order “mathematical instruments”). Then, one day, he disappears and so does his best math student, Gerald Pikestaffe. The old lady sees them hovering in some new dimension inside the mirror, faints and later, predictably, the mirror breaks and all links are lost.

    There appears to be absolutely no connection between mathematics and finding a new direction in the mirror. The only point where it could have actually gotten interesting was where the landlady sees Thorley inside the mirror. The description seems to imply that the reality inside the mirror is similar to a Poincare disk. When Thorley sees the old woman, he starts approaching her and the author describes it as:

    “Mr. Thorley’s advance, however, had two distracting peculiarities - that as he drew nearer he moved not in a straight line but a curve. As a skater performs “edges”, though on both feet instead of on one, he swept gracefully and with incredible speed in her direction. The other peculiarity was that with each step nearer, his figure grew smaller. It lessened in height. He seemed, indeed, to be moving in two directions at once. He became diminutive.”

    A shame that the author did not venture further. At least he could have salvaged some educational value out of blandness.